Who Gets to Keep the Wedding Ring After Divorce?
Same Day & After Hours Appointments Available | In-Person or Zoom Meetings | Over 20 Years Experience
They say diamonds are forever, but unfortunately, marriages do not always last that long. When a relationship ends, the division of the property that has been collected becomes a central focus, often turning sentimental items into points of contention. One of the most common questions divorcing couples ask is simple yet emotionally charged: “Do I have to give the ring back?” The answer to who keeps the ring often depends on timing and, in certain cases, the specific circumstances of the breakup.
At Reifman Law Offices, we understand that divorce is never easy. We strive to make the law simple and our clients confident as they handle these difficult transitions. Whether you are in Schaumburg, Northbrook, or the surrounding areas, our goal is to provide affordable, compassionate representation to help you move forward.
How Are Gifts Treated When Dividing Property in a Divorce?
In many cases, the timing of when the ring was given determines who gets to keep it.
- Engagement Rings: Courts often view an engagement ring as a “conditional gift.” The condition is the marriage itself. If the wedding never takes place, the ring usually goes back to the giver. However, once the marriage occurs, the condition is met. The ring then typically becomes the recipient’s separate property, meaning they get to keep it after a divorce.
- Wedding Bands: Since these are exchanged during the ceremony, they are often considered gifts given during the marriage. Gifts between spouses might be considered marital property subject to division, or they might be deemed the separate property of the recipient.
- Upgrades and Anniversaries: Rings purchased later in the marriage as upgrades or anniversary gifts are more likely to be classified as marital property, especially if marital funds were used to buy them.
The exact classification of your ring as marital or separate property will depend on your unique circumstances.
Are There Any Conduct-Based Exceptions?
While Illinois courts have moved toward “no-fault” based decisions for property, conduct can still play a role in specific situations regarding engagement rings. If the wedding is called off before it happens, for instance, the court may look at who broke the engagement to determine what happens to the ring. In the context of a divorce, however, fault (such as infidelity) rarely dictates who keeps the ring. Most courts focus on the classification of the property (marital vs. separate) rather than punishing a spouse for the breakdown of the marriage.
What Will the Court Consider When Dividing Rings as Marital Property?
If the ring is determined to be marital property rather than separate property, it is subject to division. In “equitable distribution” states like Illinois, the court looks at fairness, not necessarily an equal 50/50 split. Factors the court may look at include:
- Financial Status: The court may consider the duration of the marriage and the economic circumstances of each spouse.
- Value of the Ring: If one spouse keeps a high-value diamond ring, the other spouse may receive a larger portion of other assets (like savings or real estate) to balance the financial picture.
- Marital Agreements: If the rings were addressed in a prenuptial or postnuptial agreement, the court will use the agreement to guide the division.
Evaluating Ownership With an Attorney’s Guidance
Navigating the division of assets requires a clear understanding of your rights. At Reifman Law Offices, we are committed to moving you forward so you can experience the relief of knowing this chapter is resolving. If you have questions about who will get a wedding or engagement ring in your specific situation, let us help you find the best path forward.
At Reifman Law Offices,
we will take the weight of dealing with family legal issues off of your shoulders.
Call Us 847-229-8433
Related Articles
What Our Clients say about us
I had a great experience working with my attorney during my divorce. Everything was done quickly, clearly, and without any stress. He always responded fast, explained every step, and helped with all my questions. Really appreciate his work and highly...
Working with this law office made an uncontested divorce as simple and painless as it possibly could be. Attorney Reifman was thorough, prompt, courteous, and supportive throughout the entire proceeding. I would not hesitate to recommend them if someone I...
Arkady Reifman was very professional and supportive. He explained everything clearly and made the process smooth and stress-free. Highly recommend!
Arkady was a calm, compassionate and an effective guide through a very difficult process. I'm so grateful for his professionalism and support.
Keep in mind that every divorce is different and has different complexities to it. Ours was extremely basic and I'd say start to finish, was completed in less than 90 days. Everything was sorted out rather quickly, communication was always...
Arkady was very supportive and easy to work with, he is very professional and knowledgeable. I would recommend.
Professional, communication was excellent, and super fast and easy. Highly recommend!
Not all lawyers are created equal. That being said, most lawyers I personally encountered only cared about dragging things out and making themselves richer at the expense of the people that they were representing. Mr. Arkady Reifman shines above the...
Arkady helped me from day 1 he was great from helping ease my peace of mind during all the high conflict negotiations with my EX. My case took FAR to long for what it should have been but not because...
Arkady took over in the middle of my divorce. Found him by chance, but couldn't be happier. He is very reasonable in prices, follows up promptly, but most of all he was understanding for every issue I wanted to bring...
I’m very thankful to Arkady for his assistance with my divorce! He is very knowledgeable and was always prompt with responses. I would recommend him to anyone who needs family attorney help!
Arkady Reifman is an excellent divorce attorney who delivers a high-quality service. He helped me with my case with personal attention to details, responsiveness to questions, and very good communication skills in court and in writing letters. He also speaks...
Great lawyer, to the point and gets things done.
Affordable and very helpful , gets back to you asap and updates you in timely manner , Thank you so much for your help ... If you're looking for a lawyer that has you in mind REIFMAN will not disappoint,...
Great attorney, Always available and responsive and will give the best advice!
Firstly, I want to thank Mr. Arkady Reifman for the amazing and professional services he provided me with. Whenever I had a question, he explained thoroughly and carefully and adjusted to my circumstances when I didn't understand he always did...
Arkady Reifman is an excellent attorney who really goes above and beyond for his client, I'd trust him with anything, do not hesitate to call him.
In a divorce, you need advocates. Advocates that are willing to listen, empathize with your situation and quickly ascertain what rights and entitlements one has. I was fortunate enough to be paired with Arkady Reifman. From our first meeting, I...
Very professional, straightforward and empathetic. I went through one of the most difficult times in my life and was glad to have Arkady by my side throughout the process. I was very impressed by the great level of attention that...
Arkady handled my divorce case several years ago and I would, and have, recommended him to my friends and family. I hired Arkady after another attorney has botched my case. Not only was Arkady professional and knowledgeable, he took the...
Arkady handled my divorce case. He has done a great job understanding my needs and was able to prepare a divorce contract that covered the detailed scenarios for what was needed. As a result, my divorce process was less painful...
Arkady took care of my divorce case. He has done an amazing job understanding my needs and was able to prepare a divorce contract that covered the detailed scenarios of what was needed. As a result, my divorce process was...
I was seeking a simple uncontested divorce and I came to the right place. The consultation was over an hour and was free. Arkady took the time to understand my situation and guided me through the process which others I...
I contacted Arkady for an uncontested divorce. I received a detailed extensive free consultation and was able to figure out the remainder of the details I needed to work out with my spouse in order to finalize the process. With...
I hired Arkady to help get some rights back that I should not have lost during my divorce. Ex-wife (who has full custody of our child) told daycare that my  current wife could not pick up my daughter at daycare....
I am thrilled with my results. Arkady was exceptionally professional. He was able to find a resolution for my complex situation where I thought there was no solution. He is a strong professional with a thorough knowledge of the law...
Very Reasonable rates, easy process, and thorough explanation. Arkady was recommended to me for an uncontested divorce. I had recently met my future husband and needed to get an uncontested divorce as soon as possible. Arkady provided an excellent flat...
Reasonable Rates, dedicated service, and excellent results. I had a very difficult divorce, Arkady was able to put the correct protective orders in place, got a great Guardian ad Litem for my child and helped me gain full custody. Arkady...
Professional, compassionate and knowledgeable. I worked with Arkady on my uncontested divorce. We originally thought one set of documents was going to do it for us. However, my ex hired an attorney and I needed to protect my interests. After...
I had four divorce attorneys and one real advocate. My divorce lasted for several years and I went through multiple divorce attorneys in the process. Finding that most just want to drag their feet and get paid. Arkady proved otherwise,...
I interviewed multiple firms before I decided on Arkady Reifman. After interviewing Arkady I had a very comfortable feeling and I knew that I was going with the right professional for my situation. Arkady understood the challenges and concerns I...
Arkady is a great attorney. He listens very well, commits great focus to your case and works for the best possible outcome. It is very refreshing to meet such a hardworking and compassionate advocate. I am impressed at how knowledgeable...
Arkady Reifman was recommended to me by a relative and I'm happy I decided to go with him to represent me in my divorce case. His fees are reasonable, communication was clear and to the point, and he explained the...
We contacted Arkady to help get a divorce settlement for my guy. It had been almost a year and his original divorce attorney did nothing to help. We gave him our retainer and he worked diligently to help us. Only...
Arkady Reifman is a seasoned and professional attorney. I appreciate his help in providing counsel which was effective in the completion of my case.
Mr. Reifman has handled with great discretion and high competence several matters of importance for our family and we highly recommend him.
Arkady Reifman represented me in my divorce case. He was always very supportive through a painful time in my life. I feel secure and confident every time after conversation with him. He also was always very prompt to respond to...
Thank you Mr. Arkady Reifman for representing me in my divorce case. With your guidance and experience of the law. I would recommend you to family or friends or anybody who ask for a family lawyer.
Great attorney, professional, exceeded my expectations, very thankful!!!
Attorney Arkady Reifman was professional on working on my case. Answer all my questions with everything I had. Highly recommend this Attorney
If you are in need of any legal service, talk to this firm first. Our family has used Mr. Reifman's service to resolve a complex child support matter that involved a defendant that tried every legal maneuver to delay his...
Arkady is an excellent attorney. He took my complex divorce case and handled it with compassion and pure professionalism. The result was far better than I had expected. Arkady handled my case effectively and made the process as painless as...
Contact Us Request a free consultation today !
We assist individuals and families in Cook, Lake, and DuPage counties in Illinois.
Schaumburg Office
Northbrook Office
Attorney Advertising. This information is designed for general information only. The information presented should not be construed to be formal legal advice nor the formation of a lawyer/client relationship. Past results and testimonials are not a guarantee, warranty, or prediction of the outcome of your case, and should not be construed as such. Past results cannot guarantee future performance. Any result in a single case is not meant to create an expectation of similar results in future matters because each case involves many different factors, therefore, results will differ on a case-by-case basis. By providing contact information, users acknowledge and give explicit consent to be contacted via the methods of communication provided, including SMS. Message and data rates may apply. Message frequency may vary. Reply STOP to opt out.
NUVEW | Copyright 2026 All Rights Reserved | Accessibility Notice | Privacy Policy | Disclaimer | Resources | Sitemap